Updated on Wednesday, August 26, 2009 at 12:00AM by
Danny Roddy
Updated on Sunday, December 20, 2009 at 2:38PM by
Danny Roddy
Where is the evidence that a healthy diets must contain fruit and vegetables? Is there a scrap of data out there that suggests that something deleterious will happen if you do not consume these foods? Lets take a look at the data from past and present, not listen to the experts, and we can decide for ourselves.
In 1928 Vilhjalmur Stefansson, author of Not By Bread Alone, convinced the "The American Meat Institute" to fund a year-long all meat study supervised by a panel of prestigious doctors. When Stefanson and his partner, Karsten, embarked on the all meat diet, they were closely monitored while they stayed at Bellevue hospital located in New York.
Charles Washington explains in his Zeroing In On Health Blog the details of the all meat trial:
"During the first three weeks, they ate a mixed diet with fruits, cereals, bacon and eggs, vegetables, etc. They were examined by a group of specialists. The most tedious part was the calorimeter studies. They would get in these big, wooden, coffin-like structures and they had to lay in there for three hours. They couldn’t read and had to be nearly motionless while a group of scientists peered at them and took measurements. They couldn’t even think about anything particularly stressful or pleasant.
When they were on the mixed diet, they could come and go as they pleased. Afterwards, they were on the meat and then they were put under lock and key and the scrutiny began. They could not be out of sight of at least a doctor or nurse. This was mostly to calm the skeptics who included the European authority, Dr. Hindhede, who predicted that they could not last longer than 5 days on meat. He tried it on some of his patients and they broke down in 3 days. The good doctor figured it to be physiological even though Stefansson believed it to be psychological. Dr. Francis Benedict, who performed the landmark study on fasting in 1915, was also present with his prediction that they would only last 3 weeks. This is surprising because he examined people who ate nothing. He should have been particularly interested in how these results compared to what he measured just 13 years earlier. Benedict believed that perhaps Stefansson and his men were lying about their experiences of being in good health on an exclusive meat regimen because this clearly ran counter to his experience."
Click to read more ...